Energy@Work Shared Their Experience in Saving $3.2 Million Across 21 Properties through the Pay for Performance Program

Key elements included:

1) People, Process and Products

2) Measurement and Verification (M&V) including response to COVID reductions

3) Experience with the new ieso EPP program and lessons learned

This was shared during the Energy Leaders Consortium in September

Scott Rouse and Amir Kamandlooie presented at the September Energy Leaders Consortium, hosted by Partners in Project Green. The session was conducted for Industrial Energy Professionals on demonstrating results using Measurement and Verification (M&V). Scott and Amir outlined M&V results Energy@Work has achieved, the value and process of M&V and details on the new IESO Energy Performance Program (EPP).

Contact us for a copy of the presentation.


Energy@Work's September Newsletter: News and Views

1.png
2.png
Title 1.png
image 1.png

 Benchmarking is critical to:

  • Discovering opportunities to lower energy and water consumption

  • Tracking the progress properties have made

  • Comparing buildings’ energy and water consumption to similar buildings.

Energy and Water Reporting and Benchmarking (EWRB) has been a mandated regulation in Ontario since 2018 (O. Reg.506/18).

Due to the impact of COVID-19, the government has extended the EWRB reporting deadline to October 15th, 2021.

Energy@Work is here to help!


Title 2.png
IMage 2.png

ENERGY STAR Certification is a prestigious program that recognizes building performance that is 75% or more energy efficient than similar buildings.

NEW: Effective August 30th, 2021, NRCan has added Multi-family Housing to the list of eligible property types that can receive ENERGY STAR Building Certification.

Energy@Work is proud to have assisted 16 commercial offices obtain 2020 ENERGY STAR Building Certification last year, and there is still time to obtain 2021 ENERGY STAR Building Certification ahead of the approaching December 10th deadline.

Contact Us for more details on how your commercial office or multi-family building can join NRCan's registry of Canada's ENERGY STAR Certified Buildings.
 


Title 3.png

“We’re celebrating Canadians who make a living delivering not just energy efficiency, but more comfortable homes, more prosperous businesses, healthier schools, and bigger energy savings to you and yours.”

Energy@Work has joined over 60 Canadian companies in signing up as a supporter of Energy Efficiency Day!
Learn more at the Energy-Efficiency Day website

Image 3.png

Click to watch a quick video to discover easy ways to cut back on energy use!


Title 4.png

Energy@Work’s relationship with Bala began when he led the BOMA Toronto Conservation and Demand Management program for Ontario. The program won the AEE Award because it was practical, customer centric, and achieved results.
Our collaboration continued on many fronts, including:

  • Earth Hour Challenge: expanded to the annual ‘Beyond Earth Hour Challenge’, now is approaching its 11th anniversary

  • Global Adjustment Mechanism (GAM) Workshops: held mid-May to help customers prepare for their GAM June 15th decision.

  • Workshop: Education series as well as a 3-part workshop on HVAC Pandemic Response.

Image 4.png

Advocacy:
Bala's contributions to the CRE sector have been invaluable, including:

 

  • OEB Smart Grid Working Group

  • Energy and Water Reporting and Benchmarking (EWRB), O.Reg. 506/18

  • Green Energy Act

  • Ontario’s Long Term Energy Plan

  • CDM and DSM investments, and more!


Energy Committee: Focused on energy-related matters and looks for practical solutions.
These are a small sample of Bala’s activities. Bala’s sustainability footprint is much greater, and he is going to be missed. Each of his contributions had a central focus to make Ontario ‘Strong and Proud’.

The good news is what we can expect to see from Bala in his new role as Vice President, Sustainability, Advocacy and Stakeholder Relations at BOMA Canada. Holistic solutions in response to climate change are needed today and champions such as Bala are necessary for positive change.

We wish Bala the best of luck in his new role to help BOMA Canada thrive and sustain impactful solutions in the years to come!


Title 5.png

The team at 25 York St were committed to fulfilling all aspects of the evaluation criteria for this award, including:

  • measures resulting in energy and GHG reduction

  • occupant health and safety

  • water conservation

  • commitment to continued sustainability

  • Staff awareness

Without staff awareness we believe that their achievements would not have been possible. It’s the reason we focus so much attention of the “People” component on the 3P’s: People, Process and Products. It’s the people that get ideas off the ground which generate and sustain positive change through continual maintenance and innovative solutions.

Image 5.png

“The Existing Building Award is presented to the team responsible for a commercial or institutional (hospital, government building or academic institution) project which demonstrates continuous improvement in building operation, performance, and occupant satisfaction”


Image 6a.png

Our Energy Management Action Plan (E-MAP) can be considered an “offense” approach- identifying opportunities and tackling them to maximize savings opportunities. What can be overlooked, and is possible through continual monitoring, is the potential for “defensive” savings by discovering and correcting errors.

For example, during an E-MAP meeting, Energy@Work’s Energy Manager, Lucas Oliveira, picked up on a billing error in a large commercial building.

“We noticed that the Gas bill was higher than the previous year. When comparing with 2019, it was a 134% (31,000 m3) increase.
 
By looking at the bills, I noticed that [the building] always had an "actual" bill. However, for March and April 2020, the consumption was "estimated." By looking at the Carma data, it was also possible to see the difference. Carma was reading 19,700 m3, and the bill was 54,000 m3.
 
Usually, an issue like this would correct itself in the following "actual" bill. However, this was not the case.

When I called Enbridge and explained the situation, noting the pulse factor, they realized the billing error. Now, they are correcting the mistake”
 
Monthly monitoring provided the insight necessary to catch and correct an error that might have otherwise slipped through the cracks.

Energy@Work’s E-MAP has successfully achieved over $3.2 million in savings with an investment of $500,000. 


Title 7.png
Image 7.png

The August GAM cost is $0.54 billion.

Energy@Work wants to see a greater focus on GAM cost reduction and who to speak with to ask “why?”.

GAM costs are largely Nuclear (OPG and non-OPG). However, conservation continues to be reported as the reason for GAM. Another ‘why?’ question that remains unanswered.

Energy@Work’s services includes a “GAM coach”. We maintain the importance of a GAM Strategy for either Class A or Class B to win the (GAM)e. We hold an annual GAM Workshop in May, ahead of the June 15th Decision. Our collective GAM savings have exceeded $10 million.

We assist in evaluating Class A eligibility and assess potential strategies for both Class A and B.


Title 8.png
Image 8.png

Energy@Work congratulates the top performers at this year’s BOMA Toronto race2reduce CREST Awards!

The CREST Awards recognized the ongoing efforts of the people behind the successes in reducing emissions, and initiating building performance improvements in four categories:
 
*Click on any property to view their steps to success

Avison Young Real Estate Management Services LP:
390 Bay Street:           
Winner of Performance Leadership Waste Award and Collaborative Excellence Award
 
Madison Properties Inc:
15 Toronto Street:     
Winner of Performance Leadership Electricity Award and Innovation Excellence Award
*Honorable Mention: Leadership Water

Menkes Property Management Services Ltd.:
4711 Yonge Street:    
Winner of Innovation Excellence Award
25 York Street:           
Winner of the Climate Champion Award

Crown Property Management Inc.:
90 Sheppard Avenue:            
Winner of the Climate Champion Award
180 Dundas Street West:       
*Honourable Mention: Collaborative Excellence Winner

 

Energy@Work Inc:
Tenant Category: Winner of the Innovation Excellence Award

These teams’ hard work was paramount in their achievements and Energy@Work is proud to stand amongst these teams as the winner of the Innovative Excellence Tenant Award.

Congratulations!


Stay tuned, stay connected and stay safe!

We thank everyone that has provided feedback and for your comments: positive and negative!

We appreciate to hear your thoughts and welcome your feedback on how we can improve and/or include other areas of interest to you: Please email: Requests@Energy-Efficiency.com

Thank You:
-
Energy@Work


Energy@Work is the Winner of the Collaborative and Innovative Excellence Tenant Awards!

Energy@Work is very proud to be the winner of the 2021 Innovative Excellence Tenant Award. In 2020, we were awarded the Collaborative Excellence award and have since worked to expand our efforts and share our insights to support the Commercial and Multi-res Sectors.

E@W.png

Key accomplishments:

Goal: Utilize the Energy Management Action Plan (E-MAP) to support properties in achieving their Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) strategy through innovative and collaborative practices to uncover energy efficiency potential without sacrificing tenant comfort, safety, or equipment reliability.

Action: Customized the E-MAP across 22 commercial offices in the GTA to assist in developing their strategies to support tenant health and safety. E-MAP is a 7-pillar comprehensive approach that focuses on people while providing a proven process, along with the necessary products, to achieve success. This was shared in BOMA Toronto’s “Restarting Smart – Optimizing Performance” 3-Part Series Workshop.


15 Toronto St, Managed by Madison Properties Inc, is the Winner of the Innovative Excellence and Performance Leadership Awards!

Congratulations to 15 Toronto Street, managed by Madison Properties Inc! The team was presented with 2 race2reduce CREST Awards for Innovative Excellence, and Performance Leadership in Electricity, and received an honourable mention for the Performance Leadership Water award.

Picture1.png
Picture2.png
Picture3.png

Key Accomplishments:

Property’s Goal: Identify low to no-cost opportunities to improve electricity and water performance through novel strategies and best practices.

Action: Utilized the building’s Energy Management Action Plan (E-MAP) to monitor and review monthly electricity and water consumption patterns. Through the E-MAP, and monthly energy team meetings, 5 energy efficiency measures (EEM) and 3 Water Conservation Measures (WCM) were identified and implemented.

Results: Verified savings by Toronto Hydro of 543,280 kWh and an avoided cost of $106,000!


25 York St, Managed by Menkes Property Management Services Ltd, is the Winner of the Climate Champion Award

25 Y.png

Congratulations to the team at 25 York Street, managed by Menkes Property Management Services Ltd, for winning the Climate Champion Award at the 2021 race2reduce CREST Awards!

Key accomplishments:

Property’s Goal: Reduce the impact on the natural environment while promoting the wellbeing of building occupants and employees.

Action: Implemented collaborative strategies amongst management and operations staff, tenants, occupants and third parties such as Energy@Work to reduce GHG emissions.

Results: Electricity savings of 2,555,410 kWh achieved through the E-MAP, equivalent to the annual use (kWh) of 293 homes!

Congratulations to the 25 York Street and Menkes Teams!


4711 Yonge St, Managed by Menkes Property Management Services Ltd, is the Winner of the Innovation Excellence Award

Congratulations to Menkes Property Management Services Ltd. and the team at 4711 Yonge St, the winner of the Innovation Excellence Award at the 2021 BOMA race2reduce CREST awards!

Picture13.png

Key accomplishments:

Vision: Determine the implications of COVID on HVAC Operations and how to respond.

Action: Invested in NRCan’s Self- assessment tool and guide to prepare a Current Facility Requirements (CFR), HVAC Strategy and Communication plan, as recommended for the building.

Results: Verified electricity savings were achieved!

Congratulations to the 4711 Yonge Street and Menkes Teams!


390 Bay St, Managed by Munich Reinsurance, is the Winner of the Collaboration Excellence Award

Picture1.png

Congratulations to Munich Reinsurance and the team at 390 Bay St, the winner of the Collaboration Excellence Award at the 2021 BOMA race2reduce CREST awards!

Key accomplishments:

Property Goal: To encourage participation and boost community awareness on global issues such as health, climate change and waste reduction.

Action: Adapted a digital environmental program to include the Fit Program, Green Teams and a new Dual-Stream Recycling and Waste Program. These identified key ambassadors to work in partnership with management to realize the benefits of reducing the building’s environmental footprint.

Results: Increased stakeholder engagement has yielded positive environmental impacts. Examples include: 1,470 mature trees saved, 13,097 bathtubs of water saved, the CO2 emissions from 84 cars taken off the road, the annual energy of 20 households saved, and 368 bins of garbage diverted from landfills.

Congratulations to 390 Bay Street and the Avison Young and Munich RE teams!


Energy@Work's August Newsletter: News and Views

Screenshot 2021-09-01 162231.png
Title 2.png
Redo 1.png
Image 1.png

Congratulations to our clients and team on achieving what seemed impossible!

When the COVID-19 pandemic hit in March 2020, plans for efficiency strategies were impacted greatly. Existing efficiency strategies were difficult to measure due to drastic changes in occupancy and energy use.

Energy@Work worked with EVO Guidelines to make a non-routine adjustment strategy to demonstrate electricity savings in 2020. Savings were verified by THES with incentives for 20 properties, across 12 property management companies, through the Pay-for-Performance program!

Image 2.png

In addition to Toronto Hydro’s verified the electricity savings, there was also Natural Gas, Water and other savings as a direct result of the Energy Management Action Plan (E-MAP).

A successful E-MAP is dependent on the 3 P’s:

People: Ensuring the team is organized, so that work is distributed, and members are motivated.

Process: Proven frameworks that unite the pieces seamlessly with required actions to secure successes.

Products: These ensure that the right person has the right information they need at the right time.


Redo 2.png
Image 3.png

The BOMA Toronto CREST Awards offer an opportunity to recognize the efforts of participants of the race2reduce (r2r) program who achieved top performance.

Awards will be given for the following categories:

• Performance Leadership: Awarded for implemented measures that improve performance in each of the 4 subcategories; Electricity, Gas, Water, and Waste.

• Innovative Excellence: Awards effective and creative strategies, frameworks and technologies implemented to solve problems and achieve successes, leading others in the industry to strive to match new best practices.

• Collaborative Excellence: Recognizes the partnership between the landlord, tenant, and stakeholders to drive building performance.

• Climate Champion: Demonstration of exceptional efforts to reduce emissions.

• Municipal Beacon: Recognizes demonstration of commitment from a municipality.

Energy@Work was proud to be recognized amongst the 2020 winners for the Collaborative Excellence Award!

Those that receive this award will have demonstrated collaborative efforts to bring together and engage one or more stakeholders around issues pertinent to energy efficiency and sustainability. By working together both landlords and tenants can achieve more than if either group worked alone


Redo 3.png
IMage 4.png

The Building Sciences Cluster Program Advisory Committee is tasked with ensuring that the curriculum is comprised of relevant and high-quality programs.


Students need to be prepared to enter the Building Sciences sector after completing a program at Seneca. The advisory committee, comprised of experts in the field, can help ensure students are prepared with practical and current industry information.

We thank Seneca for the opportunity to contribute and look forward to collaborating!

“Program Advisory Committee members are key players in the future success of students, graduates and Seneca. In guiding the development of Seneca programs, they help to ensure graduates are well prepared to work in their careers and contribute to their field.”


Redo 4.png
Image 5.png

This year’s theme is "Our forests - continually giving"

National Forest Week is an opportunity to celebrate and appreciate the wonders of Canada’s forests. Celebrate National Forest Week by taking a walk in the wilderness, learning more about Canada’s forest heritage, and raising awareness!

To discovery more ways to join the celebration, including a photography contest, “Treevia” contest and activities for kids, click here.


Redo 5.png
Image 6.png

July GAM cost is $0.78 billion. This is an 11.2% decrease from June’s GAM of $0.88 billion
 
Energy@Work wants to see a greater focus on GAM cost reduction and who to speak with to ask “why?”.

GAM costs are largely Nuclear (OPG and non-OPG). However, conservation continues to be reported as the reason for GAM. Another ‘why?’ question that remains unanswered.

Energy@Work’s services includes a “GAM coach”. We maintain the importance of a GAM Strategy for either Class A or Class B to win the (GAM)e. We hold an annual GAM Workshop in May, ahead of the June 15th Decision. Our collective GAM savings have exceeded $10 million.

We assist in evaluating Class A eligibility and assess potential strategies for both Class A and B.       


ST6.png
image 7.png

Through their Energy Management Action Plan (E-MAP) and a focus on the 3 P’s: People, Process and Products, 365 Bloor St E has saved enough electricity to power 84 Ontario homes for a year!

They continue to see success and are committed to their Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) strategy!


Stay tuned, stay connected and stay safe!

We thank everyone that has provided feedback and for your comments: positive and negative!

We appreciate to hear your thoughts and welcome your feedback on how we can improve and/or include other areas of interest to you: Please email: Requests@Energy-Efficiency.com

Thank You:
-
Energy@Work


Energy@Work's July Newsletter: News and Views

Title 1.png
T2.png
ST1.png

The July 8th, 2021, BOMA Toronto webinar demonstrated the value of NRCan’s EBCx approach. The 4-phase approach is a catalyst for achieving and sustaining low and no-cost savings between 8-15%, as well as tenant and occupant improvements.

Energy@Work was asked to present case studies which validated the EBCx process through verified electricity savings by Toronto Hydro. The following are examples from over 20 buildings that entered a pay-for-performance program between 2017 and 2020. These properties achieved a collective ‘avoided’ cost of $3.2 Million- nearly 17,000,000 kWh, equal to the annual electricity use of 1,922 Ontario homes!

An Energy Management Action Plan (E-MAP) is an effective means to achieve and sustain low and no-cost savings through a regular review of utility use and building performance.

For more information please contact: requests@energy-efficiency.com

Click to expand


ST2.png
JH.png

The AEEGTA Wrench of the Year awards recognize individuals that “best exemplify the spirit of hard work, hands-on responsibility, and determination that resulted in the successful implementation of an energy efficiency project in 2020 or 2021.”

Facility personnel are often overlooked in major efficiency projects, but their hard work is instrumental to the success of any project. The awards include a $300 prize for the recipient!

We were thrilled to have nominated the 2020 Wrench of the Year award recipient, James Hrenyk, Operations supervisor at 4711 Yonge Street! James was recognized for the results he helped achieve through the implementation of the 4711 Yonge Energy Management Action Plan (E-MAP).


ST3.png
SST1.png
WR.png

A 2021 survey by YouGovAmerica has shown that, of 538 Americans currently working from home, a majority want to remain home rather than return to the office. For property management, this will have many implications.

Can something be done to encourage employees to return to work?

We think developing a strategy to promote your building’s preparedness for tenants is paramount!

It is crucial that tenants are comfortable returning to the office. Ensuring that specific HVAC settings, filters, maintenance schedules, etc. are up to ASHRAE’s recommended standards can give your building occupants piece of mind.

NRCan has released an HVAC Operation self-assessment tool and guide specific to the pandemic period. It is available free from the NRCan website: 

NRCan HVAC Self-assessment tool and guide

So, will people return?
No one knows for sure. But we had to make an educated assessment to determine this year’s Global Adjustment Class A vs B decision. 

This was a difficult analysis because:
i) Buildings had to use their pre-pandemic peak demand factor (pdf) from 2019-2020,
and
ii) kWh in 2021-22 was substantially lower.

Our ‘bottom line’:
We believe that there will be a “New Norm” where the standard M-F, 9 to 5 will become the exception Vs the rule. This will mean that property management will need flexibility in their core competencies, support, and the right information to be in the strongest position to support a positive tenant experience!


ST4.png

On June 15th, commercial consumers with an average monthly demand over 1,000 kW had a decision to make: To become a Class A or B customer. COVID created many obstacles in determining the best course of action. By tailoring individual plans with each client, we can confidently predict over $1,000,000 in savings for 2021/2022! We look forward to sharing our results- stay tuned!

SST2.png

June GAM cost is $0.88 Billion.

Energy@Work wants to see a greater focus on GAM cost reduction and who to speak with to ask “why?”.

GAM costs are largely Nuclear (OPG and non-OPG). However, conservation continues to be reported as the reason for GAM. Another ‘why?’ that remains unanswered.

Energy@Work’s services includes a “GAM coach”. We maintain the importance of a GAM Strategy for either Class A or Class B to win the (GAM)e. Our collective savings have exceeded $10 million.

We assist in evaluating Class A eligibility and assess potential strategies for both Class A and B.


ST5.png
Berk Stats.png

From Linda Leister, Property Manager:

“Berkeley Castle has surpassed all the goals that were set and have gained a reputation in the Ontario property management and energy efficiency industry as a leader. We are one of the ones setting an example to all others.
 
Energy@Work is the company that has worked tirelessly with us to make sure all this happened, and we could never have achieved these goals without them.”

Berkeley Castle’s story of success is a true testament to what can be achieved when we combine the 3P’s: People, Process and Products.

  • People: Individuals drive change. Supporting the Right person with the Right information and at the Right time has proven successful to us and our clients.

  • Process: It is essential to have a proven framework, which we refer to as our E-MAP.

  • Products: We have developed our utility management “toolbox” to ensure that we can understand and effectively communicate the information that clients need to have the confidence in implementing the changes necessary to optimize and sustain performance.

Berkeley Castle has been actively engaged in their E-MAP since 2017- since then they have made amazing strides, especially considering it is a Historic Building! Recently, Berkeley received an energy efficiency lighting improvement grant. They inventoried the light fixtures and will ensure that every inefficient light is replaced (as required) with the most energy efficient option currently available.


Stay tuned, stay connected and stay safe!

We thank everyone that has provided feedback and for your comments: positive and negative!

We appreciate to hear your thoughts and welcome your feedback on how we can improve and/or include other areas of interest to you: Please email: Requests@Energy-Efficiency.com

Thank You:
-
Energy@Work